Providing evidence to improve practice

Methods

Synopses methods

This website has a searchable database of evidence for the effectiveness of actions to conserve a given species group or habitat, or to tackle a particular conservation issue.  Each synopsis is also available as a downloadable pdf.

We gather evidence by systematically collecting studies from key scientific journals. We also search reports, unpublished literature and evidence provided by advisory boards. We summarise the results of each study that are relevant to each action.

Only studies that have quantitatively monitored the effect of an action are included in a synopsis. Predictive modelling studies and studies looking at species distributions in areas with long-standing management histories (correlative studies) are excluded.

Simple key messages outline the main effects of each action.

 


We derive a list of actions by consulting an advisory board of 10-20 experts in the subject. The people who have advised us are listed here. They help us identify all the potential actions conservationists might take for a particular species group, habitat, or conservation issue. Actions are included regardless of whether current evidence suggests they are effective/ineffective or whether evidence is currently available. We aim to make comprehensive lists of actions, so we welcome suggestions if you find something missing.

Synopses for species groups and habitats focus on actions to benefit biodiversity. The soils synopsis focuses on actions to improve soil conditions and enhance soil biodiversity. The natural pest control synopsis examines actions to enhance ecosystem services that control crop pests and weeds. The aquaculture synopsis focuses on actions to improve the sustainability of Atlantic salmon and warm water prawn farming.

Lists of actions for species group or habitat are organized into categories based on the International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) classifications of direct threats and conservation actions.

The pest control and control of freshwater invasive species synopses are pilot versions, with evidence summarised for a selected set of interventions rather than the full list. A full list of interventions for enhancing natural pest control in farmland is provided in the pdf of the synopsis. We are actively seeking additional funding, especially from the food and farming sector, to complete that synopsis.

 

We search relevant scientific journals from volume one through to a recent volume (we have now searched over 180 journals). We also search reports, unpublished literature and evidence provided by our advisory boards. The aquaculture, natural pest control and soil synopses include studies found by systematically trawling through NERC’s Open Research Archive (containing 16,410 references in August 2012).

Two of our synopses used systematic mapping exercises undertaken by, or in partnership with, other institutions. Systematic mapping uses a rigorous search protocol (involving an array of specified search terms) to retrieve studies from several scientific databases.

The full list of sources used for each synopsis can be found here.

Evidence from all around the world is included in synopses.  An exception is farmland conservation, which only covers northern Europe (all European countries west of Russia, but not those south of France, Switzerland, Austria, Hungary and Romania).  Any apparent bias towards evidence from some regions reflects the current biases in published research papers available to Conservation Evidence.

 

This website describes existing evidence and shows you where to find details. It will not tell you what action to take. To help you interpret and assess the quality of the evidence presented, we describe the size and design of each study in our summary paragraphs. We use particular words to describe study design, which we explain in this table. The strongest evidence comes from randomised, replicated, controlled trials with paired sites and before and after monitoring.

The systematic map for the farmland conservation synopsis was developed by collaborators at Harper Adams University College, UK. The systematic map for the pest control synopsis was developed in partnership with collaborators at Fondation pour la Recherche sur la Biodiversité, Paris, France.